Category: Environment

COMMUNITY OUTRAGE AT O’FARRELL DECISION TO DUMP RADIOACTIVE WASTE AT KEMPS CREEK

At a public meeting in Penrith last night, Western Sydney residents have expressed alarm at Barry O’Farrell’s decision to dump 5000 tonnes of radioactive waste at Kemps Creek – a stunning breach of his promise before the 2011 election.

“Barry O’Farrell is ploughing ahead with taking radioactive dirt from Hunters Hill and dumping it on the people of Western Sydney,” Shadow Environment Minister Luke Foley said today.

This is a broken promise of epic proportions.  Mr O’Farrell assured the community that this transfer would never happen – yet tonight he dispatched his bureaucrats as the fall guys for his broken promise.

  • “To dump it in Western Sydney is stupid, it’s a threat, and it’s not the way any government ought to be behaving.” Barry O’Farrell, October 2010

Last month, the O’Farrell Government issued its Final Environmental Assessment for the waste transfer – confirming local residents’ worst fears:

  • “During the proposed Remediation Works, there exists the potential for some groups of people to receive an increase in radiation exposure.” (page 124, 8.1 Radiological Hazards)
  •  ”The half-lives of the radionuclides present in the impacted soils at the site are long, and radioactivity may not attenuate for hundreds of years. As a consequence, any waste management solution would need to be effective in the very long term.” (page 148)
  •  ”In the short term there would be some environmental impacts which would require mitigation [including] …risk of ingestion/exposure to contaminated material containing radioactive tailings and chemical compounds.” (page 233)

“The Premier’s own experts have confirmed that this soil is so toxic it will need to be monitored for radioactive decay until at least the 24th century AD.  Mr O’Farrell is condemning the people of Western Sydney to 300 years of risk from radioactive material sitting within metres from streets and homes. This decision says it all about Barry O’Farrell’s real attitude to Western Sydney.”

Penrith Labor councillor Prue Car said: “Barry O’Farrell is putting the local community last. The Government can hold public meetings until it is blue in the face – the blunt truth is Mr O’Farrell misled us.
“If this soil isn’t dangerous why not keep it in Hunters Hill?  ”If it is dangerous – none of us in Western Sydney want a bar of it.”

 

Putting the customer back in front: How to make electricity prices cheaper


A new report from the Grattan Institute’s Energy program, Putting the customer back in front: how to make electricity cheaper, presents a concrete set of proposals for substantially reducing the power bills of Australian households.

The main problem driving excessively high prices for consumers is that the regulation of electricity distribution networks is broken. Changes over recent years to the way distributors operate and charge customers have allowed them to make unduly high profits, given the relatively low level of risk they face.

Governments have also intervened to ensure that distributors deliver power at a level of reliability no serious cost-benefit analysis can justify.  Again, it is consumers who pay. To restore the balance, governments should:

  • Direct and empower the Australian Energy Regulator (AER) to set the parameters that determine customer costs and company profits, and ensure that the parameters are consistent with the low risks these businesses face.
  • Reduce the risk of political interference by transferring responsibility for setting reliability standards from state governments to the Australian Energy Market Commission (AEMC) and the AER, the national bodies that set and enforce the rules of the market.
  • Implement more robust corporate governance standards for government-owned businesses to ensure they operate as efficiently as those that are privately owned. Otherwise they should be privatized.
  • Prevent over-investment in the networks by empowering the AER to review the companies’ capital expenditure forecasts annually against credible market demand forecasts, and subject any over-expenditure to a rigorous cost-benefit analysis.

Recent rule changes proposed by the AEMC are going in the right direction, but are still too general to instill confidence that the desired result will be delivered.

Of course distribution companies should be allowed to make fair and reasonable profits. At the same time, regulators should not only have more resources and power – but should be directed – to act in the long-term interests of consumers.

The Report states the recommendations in this report could save customers about $2.2 billion a year, or $100 a year for every household, as well as creating a fairer, more efficient electricity distribution system.

O’Farrell Consigns Western Sydney to 300 Years of Nuclear Waste

Newly released documents reveal the O’Farrell Government is dumping radioactive waste – which needs to be monitored for the next 300 years – in Western Sydney.

The government’s report into moving the waste reveals:

“Long term management and monitoring (and associated funding) arrangements would need to be implemented at the disposal site for at least 300 years.” *

The feasibility review into disposal options for the waste from a former uranium smelter at Hunters Hill also shows the government has manipulated the data to avoid it being classified as radioactive – so it can be dumped at Kemps Creek.  

 “This report confirms Barry O’Farrell has broken his promise to the people of Western Sydney and is dumping radioactive waste from the North Shore in their backyard,” Opposition Leader John Robertson said.   

“The Premier’s own experts confirm the government will need to provide funding to monitor the radioactive waste for the next 300 years at Kemps Creek.

“This decision says it all about Barry O’Farrell’s real attitude to Western Sydney.” 

Shadow Environment Minister, Luke Foley said the report showed the government had found ‘radioactive hot spots’ in the waste, but twisted the data to avoid classifying it as such.

“The O’Farrell Government has manipulated the data that shows the waste is radioactive – so it can be sent to Kemps Creek,” Mr Foley said.

The report clearly states:

 “Radioactive material was detected at varying concentrations across the area… one of the samples exceeded the criteria for restricted solid waste.”

 “Therefore for the purpose of the radiological results discussion, the majority of the areas were combined into a single grouping covering the majority of the site (excluding LG4). This impacts on the potential remediation actions of the site, as the remaining areas (LG1 and LG2) will radiologically be treated as a single area.” **

 “It is clear the O’Farrell Government has reclassified the data so it can dump the North Shore’s radioactive waste in Western Sydney,” Mr Foley said.

“This report proves once and for all that Barry O’Farrell is dumping radioactive waste – that will need to be monitored until the 24th century – at Kemps Creek.”

Barry O’Farrell’s original promise to keep the waste away from Kemps Creek:

“To dump it in Western Sydney is stupid, it’s a threat, and it’s not the way any government ought to be behaving.”            (Barry O’Farrell, October 2010)

The Putty Valley is no place for the Coal Seam Gas industry

by Luke Foley

 Nine days ago I visited the Putty Valley and met with local residents.

 The Putty Valley is mid way between Windsor and Singleton, nestled between the Wollombi and Yengo national parks, and within the electoral district of Upper Hunter and the local government area of Singleton.

 It is a place of indescribable beauty. A place where heaven meets earth.

 The Putty Valley immediately brought to my mind the Clogher Valley in County Tyrone, in the north of Ireland.

 My wife was born and reared in that valley, and we were married there.

 The Putty Valley and the Clogher Valley have both been dominated by dairy farms for generations.

 In Putty Valley, most of the dairy farms have given way to grazing.

 The rugged terrain of the wilderness and mountain ranges surrounding Putty is reminiscent of County Tyrone’s Sperrin Mountains.

 The Wollemi National Park encompasses the largest wilderness area in New South Wales, and is part of the Greater Blue Mountains World Heritage Area, as is the Yengo National Park.

 The area is home to one of the world’s great biological mysteries: how did the Wollemi pine, the ‘dinosaur tree’, survive 5 million years secluded in a single canyon before being discovered?

 The rural environment of the Putty Valley is today threatened by the coal seam gas industry.

 So are the surrounding national parks, notwithstanding their protected status under the National Parks and Wildlife Act.

 We know that the extraction of large volumes of water impacts on connected surface and groundwater systems.

 On 19 August 2011 Dart Energy commenced drilling a core hole to explore for coal seam gas at a property on Putty Road, in the Putty Valley area.

 The bore site is just over 500 metres from the boundary of a World Heritage listed area of international significance.

 The exploration site is 40 metres from Long Wheeney Creek which runs into Putty Creek, Wollemi Creek and the pristine and protected Colo River through the Wollemi National Park, before joining the Hawkesbury River.

 Prior to the election, the Liberal and National parties announced that they would introduce a Strategic Regional Land Use Policy to “strike the right balance between our important agricultural, mining and energy sectors, while ensuring the protection of high value conservation lands“.

 The Coalition’s election policy stated that “The NSW Liberals and Nationals believe that agricultural land and other sensitive areas exist in NSW where mining and coal seam gas extraction should not occur.”

 Today’s announcement of the Government’s Draft Upper Hunter Strategic Regional Land Use Plan provides no comfort whatsoever to the people of the Putty Valley.

 The protection of strategic agricultural lands and high conservation values is left to a process which can sideline water protection and be sidelined itself if the government deems the project to be ‘exceptional’.  

 There’s no certainty for sustainable agriculture nor threatened habitats.

 I do accept a role for gas in this state’s energy mix.

 I also believe that there should be no go areas.

 The NSW Liberals and Nationals used to believe this too – at least until polling day last year.

 I believe that the Putty Valley is a perfect example of a sensitive area that should exclude mining and extractive industries, in order to protect its significant environmental values.

 Allowing the coal seam gas industry into the Putty Valley would create a pustule of industrialisation in the heart of the Wollemi and Yengo World Heritage areas.

 The Putty Valley is no place for the gas industry.

  Luke Foley MLC is the Leader of the Opposition in the NSW Legislative Council

 

Connect now

Subscribe

Subscribe to LAWCRIMEPOLITICS.COM

Email address:

Search

Progressing the Social Democratic Agenda